March 8, 2018ArticleThe Trials and Tribulations of Patent Eligibility of Natural Products at the PTABAs patent prosecution practitioners, we often look for direction from the judges at the PTAB, particularly when agreement cannot be reached at the examining level. This is very evident when there is imprecise guidance as to what constitutes patent eligible subject matter for inventions including natural products following the Supreme Court's decision in Myriad as well as the various iterations of PTO guidance and training materials. Here is a tale of two cases with two different panels (yet each panel interestingly includes one common APJ (New)) and each panel renders very different decisions. More
January 1, 2005ArticleAn Odd YearIP Law & Business