Blog

http://www.patentspostgrant.com/

Recent Blog Posts

  • Another WiFi One Hint from the CAFC "Closely Tied" Language of Cuozzo & Institution-Centric Statutes  The en banc opinion on the scope of the AIA's appeal bar (35 U.S.C. §§ 324(e)/314(d)) remains outstanding in WiFi One.  Still, we have seen a few opinions from the Federal Circuit as of late that nibble around the edges of this issue.  From these decisions, we see the Court focusing on the statute underlying the appealed issue, and whether or not that statute is tied, in timing or substance, to the institution stage.... More
  • A Post-Grant Lesson for Patent Prosecutors Are You Properly Corroborating Your In Re Katz Declarations?  Every so often a decision comes out of the USPTO's Patent Trial & Appeal Board (PTAB) or the Federal Circuit that has immediate value for patent prosecutors. Last week, in EmeraChem Holdings, LLC v. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.,the Federal Circuit considered the degree of corroboration necessary to disqualify a prior art reference as an inventor's own work.  In EmeraChem the Cout made clear that such corroboration may be within the inventor declaration itself,... More
  • PTAB Conference 6/29 @ USPTO USPTO Headquarters to Host Half-Day PTAB Conference  As the Patent Trial & Appeal Board (PTAB) has previously announced, it will host a half-day Judicial Conference on June 29, 2017 from 1-5PM.  The conference will be held in the Madison Auditorium.  The program will be directed toward both AIA trial proceedings and ex parte appeal practices. The detailed agenda and webcast link are found below:... More
  • AIA Trials Unconstitutional? Don't Bet on It High Court to Review Constitutionality of AIA Trials  The Supreme Court has had at least three occasions over the past 7 months to review the constitutionality of AIA trial proceedings — it declined all three invitations. Thus, the writing appeared to be on the wall when the same question was posed recently in Oil States Energy Services v. Greene’s Energy Group.  But, then the Federal Circuit wavered somewhat as to its conviction in its own precedent on point.  When asked to reconsider... More
  • Preliminary Response Evidence Should Focus on Technology Preliminary Responses Accompanied by Declaration Evidence: Updated Results   Back on May 1st of 2016, the Patent Trial & Appeal Board (PTAB) began to accept new testimonial evidence with patentee preliminary responses.  The PTAB implemented this change to address complaints of patentees who claimed they were disadvantaged by previous rules precluding such new evidence from accompanying a preliminary response. It was argued that the previous rules were especially imbalanced as almost all petitions were accompanied by petitioner declaration evidence, and that absent evidence in... More